Showing posts with label philadelphia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philadelphia. Show all posts

7.07.2011

Reflections on The Art of The Steal


I recently watched The Art of the Steal, the gripping documentary about the Barnes Collection of impressionist, post-impressionist and modern art.

I have been fascinated by the battle over the control of the Barnes Foundation.  It’s fascinating to me in both of my worlds, since for my day job, I’m a paralegal who specializes in estate administration.

Before watching the movie, I didn’t have a strong opinion on the matter.  I thought what was most important was maintainence of the artwork itself.  I felt the actual hang of the art was also important.  But, then I figured they could easily recreate that at the new place as well.  As a paralegal, I know there are loopholes around everything and what they are trying to do is most likely legal.  (And there is a judge involved, so, the judge should be the one to make the decision.)

However, after watching the documentary and putting more thought into it, I am actually infuriated by the chain of events that led to whom had the ultimate control of the Barnes.

  1. The Barnes should not be moving at all to begin with.
  2. A question that I have not actually seen answered:  Is the new location’s main focus education?  The art was hung and the foundation began for education.  Will this new location serve as a school?
  3. Dr. Barnes specifically drafted his will to keep his art collection out of the hands of the Philadelphia social elite/Philadelphia Museum of Art, whom he hated.  Now they have control of it.
  4. As a museum on the Parkway in downtown Philadelphia, surely this collection is meant as a tourist attraction.  Philadelphia aggressively promotes its tourism, and this will be just another attraction.  The artwork is stuck in a battle about money and politics.  Just the opposite of what Dr. Barnes wanted.

Lincoln University

I have visited Lincoln University.  It’s a tiny school in a rural area.  (The town itself is actually called Lincoln University, that is the size of the town.)  After the original Board of Directors all passed on, Lincoln University was in control of the Barnes Foundation. 

It was an odd, eccentric choice, but it was Dr. Barnes’ choice to make.  I also believe that this was the unraveling of the Barnes Foundation.  The wrong person from Lincoln was in charge of the foundation, which led to a multitude of lawsuits that the Foundation had to pay for.  Then ultimately the Foundation had financial issues.  Not to mention, I don’t believe that they actually knew the value of the collection, and maybe they thought they were in more trouble than they actually were.

A series of unfortunate events and now here we are waiting for the Barnes to be placed in the mass approved building in the highly traveled Benjamin Franklin Parkway, sitting down the road as the little brother to the Philadelphia Museum of Art.  For all purposes, run by the Philadelphia Museum of Art, which is the very thing that Dr. Barnes was trying to protect his art from with his will.

I can understand the argument that more people will be able to view the art in the new location, however, this was Dr. Barnes’s art. 

It does not belong to the City of Philadelphia,
It does not belong to the State of Pennsylvania,
It does not belong to the Philadelphia Museum of Art. 

It was Dr. Barnes’ art and HIS decision what to do with it.  He wanted it to stay where it is to be used in the school that he began. 

I don’t think just because the artwork is that of the masters that it suddenly becomes public property and should be controlled by the public (or politicians or the social elite.)

It infuriates me, to say the least.

Have you seen the movie The Art of the Steal?  Did it change your opinion about the situation (or solidify it more)?

What do you think about this situation?  Should the artwork of the masters be available to be viewed by everyone?  Or is a private collection, just that, private?

(please leave your views below in "comments")

7.04.2011

Should the Barnes Collection be Moved?

Postman

The Barnes collection contains priceless impressionist, post-impressionist and early modern paintings, among other art.  It is really fascinating to think about what goes into moving such a priceless (well, the estimated value is $25 billion) and massive collection (2500 objects, including 800 paintings) - the armored trucks, the FBI, etc. - but most people are interested in something else altogether.

Should the Barnes Collection even be moved?


Some opponents of that move proffer that Barnes had his own creative vision on how the paintings are arranged and should not be disturbed.  Some say that his will is being broken by moving the collection. 

Those who do not oppose the move say that what matters most is the paintings themselves, and as long as they are accessible, it doesn't matter where they are.

I find this particularly fascinating because not only am I interested in art, but I also happen to be a paralegal who specializes in estate administration.

Either way you look at it, I must say I'm sad that I didn't get to see the artwork in its original home.  To see Dr. Barnes' vision on how the pieces should be hung and arranged.  And to amass that amount of beautiful artwork! 

It's too late now to see it in its original location - the final tour has been done and the lights are out.

According to the Barnes Foundation, the new location in Philadelphia has been designed to invoke the same intimate feeling as the original site in Merion.  The paintings will be arranged in a manner similar to Dr. Barnes' original vision.  There will be gardens in the new location as well.

The Foundation will continue to maintain and expand the gardens at the Merion location, opening up new possibilities for horticulture education.

The main reason for the move is to allow for more visitors to the collection, since there are strict rules about visiting galleries in its current location.

This argument has been going on for years and the decision only recently made in the court system.  A documentary movie, The Art of the Steal, was made about the controversy.  

A cool feature of the Barnes Foundation's website is a webcam on the new building in downtown Philadelphia that shows a new photo every 15 minutes.

Whatever your opinion on whether or not the collection should be moved, the new Philadelphia location is slated to open to the public in late Spring of 2012. 

I would love to know your opinion on this.  Please leave your thoughts below in the comments.